• 2003-Present Reverend Monsignor John J. O'Keefe (Pastor)
• 2007-2009 Reverend Francis J. Samoylo
• 2003-2005 Reverend Kevin Gallagher
• 2001-2007 Reverend Angelo Palermo, S.A.C. 45th Anniversary, Mass Card
• 2001-2004 Reverend Francis Ong
• 1999-2000 Reverend Salvador Anonuero
• 1997-2003 Reverend Monsignor Rudolph J. Eisler (Pastor) With Cardinal O'Connor, At the St. Patrick's Day Parade,Article, Mass Card
• 1997-2001 Reverend Leo R. Prince
• 1985-1997 Reverend Monsignor James Doyle (Pastor) Background, Father Doyle becomes a Monsignor, Monsignor Doyle goes to St. Joseph's
• Moving of the Religious Education Center
• 1995-2002 Reverend George Stewart
• 1994-19?? Reverend O'Sullivan
• 1994-1995 Reverend Dominic Amadi 
• 1990-2003 Deacon William J. Donovan
• 1990-2009 Monsignor Harrington  a brief biography, at the St. Patrick's Day Parade, with Cardinal O'Connor, News Paper Article of his funeral mass, Mass Card
• 1990-1993 Reverend William A. Scafidi 
• 1988-1999 Sister Maryann Lawlar, O.P.
• 1980-2002 Deacon William D. Tobin
• 19??-19?? Sister Eileen Reilly, O.P.
• 19??-19?? Sister Micaela Connolly, O.P.
• 1997-1987 Reverend John J. Duff
• 1973-1985 Reverend John J. McKenna (Pastor)
• 1973-1980 Reverend Edwin J. Kenny
• 1970-1990 Sister Ann Connolly
• 1967-1973 Monsignor Michael Bell (Pastor)
• 1949-???? Reverend John N. Brooks 
• 1947-1949 Reverend Thomas A. Cunningham
• 1947-1947 Reverend Bernard P. Corrigan
• 1945-1947 Reverend Edward J. Kelly
• 1944-1945 Reverend Martin G. Fitzpatrick
• 1942-1944 Reverend Laurent Youn
• 1942-1942 Reverend Charles A. Clancy
• 1941-1942 Reverend Harold J. Sullivan
• 1939-1941 Very Reverent Charles M. Walsh
• 1939-1967 Reverend Michael J. Toner (Pastor) Burial Mass Card
• 1938-1939 Reverend Hugh A. Cronin
• 1937-1938 Reverend Clifford J. Smith
• 1937-1937 Reverend Joseph D. Fitzgerald
• 1930-1939 Reverend Cornelius V. Hayes (Pastor) in 1931
• 1923-1930 Reverend Charles M. Woods (Pastor)
• 1914-1923 Reverend John F. Meehan (Pastor)
• 1905-1914 Reverend John B. Slater (Pastor)
• 1895-1905 Reverend John G. McCormick (Pastor)

Our Vocations

• 2006 Reverend  Brian Taylor (Diocesan Priest) First Mass
• 2003 Sister Maureen of the Precious Blood (the former Janice Lanzilotti) Carmel of the Holy Family
• 1990 Reverend  Andrew Carrozza (Diocesan Priest)
• 1997 Reverend  Joseph Fallon (Diocesan Priest)
• ???? Sister M. Joan of the Sisters of Charity (the former Regina Demarest)
• ???? Sister M. Pauline of the Sisters of Mercy (the former Philomena Beckerle)
• ???? Sister M. Rosanne of the Sisters of Charity (the former Theresa Pirkl)
• ???? Reverend Ronald of the Salvatorian Fathers (the former Fred Bullingham)
• 1972 Reverend  John Vigilanti (Diocesan Priest)
• 1967 Reverend  John J. McIvor (Diocesan Priest)
• ???? Reverend  David J. Riley (Diocesan Priest)